Skip to main content.
Navigation:
Ithaca NY's Definitive Guide to Local Pizza

How do you find a pizza joint that serves the style of pizza you like without eating at every shop in town? Ithaca Pizza Review, that's how. Each review will include a photo of a pie and a slice so you can see exactly what they serve. Since taste, like art, is subjective to a degree, we will do our best to present the objective facts of the pizza - what kind of pizza is it, how prompt was the delivery - as well as present the subjective experience of eating the pizza.

1. A complete list of Places That Serve Pizza in town.
2. Pizza special offers: The Best Pizza Deals in town.

New Pizza Place: North East Pizza at Scale House Brewpub
North East Pizza, at 23 Cinema Drive (at the Small Mall) opened a few months back. North East Pizza is part of and connected to the Scale House Brewpub, they serve Pizza, Calzones Subs, Wings, Salads, Calzones and fresh tasty beer that is brewed onsite. For dine in, pick up or delivery to Cornell, Cayuga Heights and the northeastern part of Ithaca. 607-257-2757 Read the Review

Review: Northeast PizzaAmazing Pizza + Fresh Beer



Joe's RestaurantPrettiest pie in town - Amazing crust
Read the Review

New York PizzeriaWorth the drive to Trumansburg
Read the Review


CollegeTown PizzaIthaca's Best NY Style Thin Crust
Read the Review